Most people engage with astrology at the fun level, checking compatibility with a crush or laughing at memes about their sign’s worst habits. But the zodiac has always had a darker side, and every sign’s personality includes a trait that ranks as its creepiest. The same intensity that makes Scorpios magnetic can tip into vengefulness, and the adaptability that helps Gemini charm a room can just as easily help them deceive it.
Carl Jung, a Swiss psychiatrist, called these hidden tendencies the shadow self, and when they go unchecked, the results range from toxic relationships to murder. Researchers have analyzed the birth dates of serial killers and found certain signs appear far more often than chance would predict. This isn’t about labeling anyone dangerous. It’s about recognizing the shadow you carry and what happens when you refuse to look at it.
What Is the Shadow Self?
Carl Jung spent decades studying the unconscious mind, first alongside Sigmund Freud and later through his own framework called analytical psychology. In his 1951 book Aion, Jung formalized what he called the shadow self, the traits and impulses you’ve rejected because they feel unacceptable. The shadow isn’t evil. It’s just the parts of yourself you’d rather not acknowledge.
Refusing to face them doesn’t make them disappear. The qualities you suppress leak out sideways as passive aggression, self-sabotage, or explosions that seem to come from nowhere. Every zodiac sign carries both light and shadow, and for most people, these darker tendencies stay manageable. Although for a small number, they don’t.
The Numbers Behind the Names
ZodiacSign.com compiled the birth dates of 485 serial killers to find out which signs appeared most often. Four dominated the list. Cancer, Pisces, Sagittarius, and Scorpio each produced 46 killers, together accounting for nearly 40% of the dataset, while Gemini and Taurus tied for the fewest at 27. But frequency doesn’t tell the whole story. Capricorn ranked mid-pack in total numbers yet claimed 813 victims combined, averaging 19 kills per person and making it the deadliest sign by body count. Virgo killers averaged just seven. Some signs produce more killers, and others produce more efficient ones.
Why Earth Signs Dig Deep
Earth signs produced the fewest serial killers in the data, with Taurus, Virgo, and Capricorn combining for 109. That number seems reassuring until you look at what those killers accomplished. Earth signs are patient by nature, the kind of people who plan and build and wait because they know delayed gratification pays off.
That patience creates empires and careers, but it also means they can execute long-term schemes that other signs would abandon out of impatience or guilt. When earth signs turn dark, they don’t explode. They construct, and the same methodical nature that makes them reliable makes them chillingly efficient when their goals become violent.
Taurus (April 20 – May 20): Possessive Obsession
Taurus values stability and comfort, but that need for security can curdle into possession. When a Taurus decides something belongs to them, letting go stops being an option. H.H. Holmes took this to its most literal extreme when he spent years building Chicago’s Murder Castle, a hotel designed to trap guests in hidden rooms and dispose of them in its basement crematorium. He timed its completion for the 1893 World’s Fair because he knew the flood of tourists would bring victims straight to his door, he didn’t act on impulse. He built infrastructure for murder and waited for it to pay off.
Virgo (August 23 – September 22): Perfectionism as Punishment
Virgo notices everything, and that precision makes them excellent editors. It also turns every person into a document full of errors, and some Virgos decide the world needs correcting. Ed Gein brought methodical care to his crimes in Plainfield, Wisconsin, and Albert DeSalvo did the same as the Boston Strangler. Dutch statistician Jan Ruis analyzed nearly 300 serial killers‘ birth charts for research in the journal Correlation and found Virgo among four mutable signs that appeared most often. Mutable signs adapt to their circumstances, but when reality refuses to cooperate with their need for order, they don’t always accept the mess.
Capricorn (December 22 – January 19): Cold, Calculated Ambition
Capricorns plan. That’s usually a virtue, but when ambition turns violent, the same patience that builds careers lets them keep going longer than other signs would. Harold Shipman was a British doctor who killed an estimated 250 patients over decades, making him the deadliest serial killer in modern history. Dean Corll, the Candy Man of Houston, murdered at least 28 young men. The Killer.cloud database, which tracks over 650 serial killers, places Capricorn at the top with 55. That number differs slightly from the ZodiacSign.com analysis, but both sources agree on one thing. Capricorn killers claim more victims on average than any other sign.
Read More: Beware: This is The Most Dangerous Zodiac Sign
Why Air Signs Go Cold
Air signs sit in the middle of the data, with Gemini, Libra, and Aquarius combining for 115 serial killers. These signs live in their heads, maintaining enough emotional distance to see situations clearly. That distance makes them good problem-solvers and mediators. It also has a cost. When air signs stop feeling their own emotions, they lose access to other people’s too, and empathy becomes something they understand in theory rather than feel. A mind that sees all angles can rationalize almost anything.
Gemini (May 21 – June 20): The Two-Faced Mask
Gemini’s duality passes for charm because the mental agility that makes someone a magnetic conversationalist also makes them a natural liar. Jeffrey Dahmer convinced neighbors everything was fine, even when the smell from his apartment said otherwise. David Berkowitz kept a normal postal job while writing taunting letters to the police as the Son of Sam. Samuel Little drifted through 61 confirmed murders over three decades, often questioned but never held because he knew how to play harmless. ZodiacSign.com found Gemini among the least common signs for serial killers, but the Geminis who do kill wear their masks so well that the truth only surfaces once they’re caught.
Libra (September 23 – October 22): The People-Pleasing Predator
Libra wants harmony at all costs, which means swallowing resentment rather than expressing it. That anger doesn’t disappear just because it’s silent. Years of keeping the peace can build pressure that the peacekeeper no longer controls, and the result isn’t always obvious. Patrick Kearney murdered at least 28 young men in Southern California while living an ordinary life with his partner, and Bill Longley killed 32 as a 19th-century outlaw. Libra’s shadow isn’t the explosion. It’s the smile, an agreeable face worn so long they’ve stopped noticing the rage behind it.
Aquarius (January 20 – February 18): Detached Extremism
Aquarius prides itself on objectivity, and that works until it stops seeing individuals and start seeing statistics. When people become numbers, compassion becomes impossible. Gary Ridgway murdered at least 49 women as the Green River Killer, and Luis Alfredo Garavito is believed to have killed over 190 children in Colombia. Aquarius operates by an internal moral compass that answers to no one else. When that compass fails, there’s nothing external to catch them. Humanitarian ideals twist into vigilante justification, and independence becomes isolation so complete that other people stop feeling real.
Why Fire Signs Burn
Fire signs climb higher on the list, with Aries, Leo, and Sagittarius combining for 123 serial killers. Their intensity fuels ambition and the kind of charisma that draws people in, but fire doesn’t care what it burns. When these signs lose control, confidence slides into aggression and restlessness starts chasing thrills that healthy outlets can’t provide. Energy with nowhere to go will find somewhere destructive.
Aries (March 21 – April 19): Explosive Impulse
Aries charges through life headfirst, and when that confidence meets resistance, it can flash into rage. But the need to dominate doesn’t always look like anger. Keith Hunter Jesperson craved recognition so badly that he sent letters to media outlets signed with smiley faces to claim credit for his murders, earning him the name Happy Face Killer. Charles Sobhraj used charm to control his victims across Asia before disposing of them, earning a different nickname, the Bikini Killer. Both wanted to win, and neither cared what winning cost.
Leo (July 23 – August 22): Narcissistic Hunger
Leo craves the spotlight, and when admiration fades, some Leos manufacture drama just to feel seen again. Usually that looks like gossip or attention-seeking, but the impulse can turn violent. Myra Hindley wanted the world to know her name, and alongside partner Ian Brady, she committed crimes so notorious they still dominate British true crime decades later. Leo actually produces fewer serial killers than most signs, probably because murder requires secrecy and Leos struggle to stay hidden. But when admiration isn’t enough, fear works just as well.
Sagittarius (November 22 – December 21): Thrill-Seeking Without Conscience
Ted Bundy confessed to murdering at least 28 women, and even facing execution, he couldn’t stop performing. He acted as his own attorney, flirted with the judge, and waved to cameras with the confidence of someone who believed charm could get him out of anything. Bundy was a Sagittarius, and his courtroom behavior shows what happens when the sign’s impulsiveness has no conscience behind it. Sagittarius chases experience without stopping to ask whether it should. For most, that means spontaneous trips or oversharing at parties. For Bundy, the thrill he chased was control over whether someone lived or died.
Why Water Signs Lead the List
Water signs come last because the data demands it. Cancer, Scorpio, and Pisces together account for 138 serial killers in the ZodiacSign.com study, 28% of the total and 27% of all victims. These signs feel everything, absorbing emotions from people around them until they can’t separate their own pain from everyone else’s. That sensitivity becomes intuition and empathy when it has somewhere to go. When it doesn’t, the same intensity turns inward as self-destruction or outward as violence. Water signs don’t detach like air or explode like fire. They drown, and sometimes they take others with them.
Cancer (June 21 – July 22): Emotional Weaponry
Cancer feels everything deeply, which makes them nurturing when they’re loved and dangerous when they’re wounded. No one knows where to strike like someone who has spent their life reading emotions, and hurt Cancers don’t forget who hurt them. Carl Panzram turned childhood abuse into indiscriminate hatred and became one of history’s most openly violent killers. Genene Jones, a pediatric nurse, murdered infants in her care by injecting them with drugs so she could play hero during resuscitation attempts. Both used what Cancer does naturally, reading vulnerability. But instead of protecting it, they exploited it.
Scorpio (October 23 – November 21): Vengeful Obsession
Scorpios don’t forgive, and they don’t need to act angry to be planning revenge. Charles Manson orchestrated murders through psychological manipulation without getting his own hands dirty. Belle Gunness lured suitors to her Indiana farm with promises of romance, then killed them for insurance money. Neither lost control. Both waited, planned, and struck when the moment served them. Scorpios’ capacity for patience means a grudge can simmer for years while they build something the other person won’t see coming until it’s already too late.
Pisces (February 19 – March 20): Escapism Into Darkness
John Wayne Gacy murdered at least 33 young men while performing at children’s parties as a clown. Richard Ramirez terrorized Los Angeles as the Night Stalker. Aileen Wuornos killed seven men along Florida highways. All three were Pisces, a sign that absorbs emotion from everyone around them until the weight becomes unbearable. Pisces spend their lives looking for escape from a world that feels like too much, and most find relief in fantasy, creativity, or numbness. Some find darker exits.
The Shadow You Carry
None of this means your Scorpio coworker is plotting revenge or your Capricorn neighbor is keeping bodies in the basement. Even the creepiest trait in your personality profile exists on a spectrum, and recognizing yours doesn’t make you dangerous. It makes you aware. Most Leos channel their need for attention into careers rather than crimes, and most Virgos direct their perfectionism at spreadsheets rather than people.
The serial killers who share your sign took their darkest tendencies to an endpoint almost no one reaches. Understanding your shadow gives you power over it, not the other way around. You’re not your worst impulse, but knowing what it looks like helps you catch it before it catches you. Check your friends’ birth charts if you want. Just don’t look too closely.
Faith & Spirituality Disclaimer: Articles exploring faith and spirituality are intended to encourage reflection and understanding, not to define doctrine or assert factual certainty. Spiritual beliefs and experiences differ across individuals and traditions and exist alongside scientific and real-world perspectives. Readers are invited to approach these topics with openness, discernment, and respect for differing viewpoints.
Read More: 3 Zodiac Signs Set to Transform in a Powerful New Era This Week