Skip to main content

Cynthia Erivo’s casting as Jesus in a high‑profile staging of Jesus Christ Superstar at Los Angeles’s Hollywood Bowl has ignited one of the most heated online conversations of the summer. Fans and critics are sharply divided. In early August 2025, the renowned Tony‑winning actress and singer took on the title role in this rock musical. Adam Lambert playing Judas opposite her. The production, directed and choreographed by Sergio Trujillo, ran from August 1 to August 3, and featured musical direction by Stephen Oremus.

Since the casting was announced in mid‑July, commentary has ranged from enthusiastic support to outright condemnation. Some have hailed the choice as a progressive and inclusive reimagining of a classic, while others have decried it as an unnecessary break with tradition. A frequent criticism centers on the idea that Jesus, a male religious figure, should not be portrayed by a woman. Conversely, supporters argue that the theatrical and interpretive nature of the piece invites boundary‑pushing artistic choices.

A Visual Design That Sparked Reactions

The performance visuals intensified these reactions even further. Erivo appeared in a tattered, white dress and, notably, long, claw‑like acrylic nails. Her shaved head and gaunt styling, paired with her dramatic stage presence, prompted many viewers online to react with shock and discomfort. Comments ranged from calling the look “eerie” and “frightening” to blunt declarations that labeled the portrayal as “a demon.”

Critics accused the production of seeming more like a provocation than an inspired interpretation. Social media users questioned the production’s intentions and appeal, making comparisons to cultural provocation rather than reverent adaptation. One user commented that the show felt like “Bride of Frankenstein” rather than Jesus Christ Superstar, and others suggested that the casting choice felt overtly political rather than purely artistic.

Reactions from the Cast and Production Team

While negative responses were widespread, others within the creative team and cast defended the decision. Among them, Adam Lambert, who performed as Judas, emphasized that the teachings at the heart of Jesus Christ Superstar transcend gender and that the story can resonate beyond traditional casting norms.

Cynthia Erivo spoke directly to critics, emphasizing that the production is a musical, rooted in performance rather than doctrinal messaging. She encouraged audiences to come expecting a bold theatrical experience, inviting them to “sing her face off” and remember that this is, at its core, a stage show intended to entertain and provoke in equal measure.

Historical Context and Artistic Precedents

This is not Erivo’s first engagement with Jesus Christ Superstar material. In 2020, she portrayed Mary Magdalene in an all‑female reinterpretation of the musical, Jesus Christ Superstar: She Is Risen. That earlier project similarly embraced creative re‑casting and inclusive casting principles.

Unconventional casting of religious figures in this musical has precedent. For example, in 2018’s NBC live‑concert production, John Legend, a Black man, played Jesus. That version also drew acclaim and debate without the same intensity of backlash seen in the 2025 Hollywood Bowl rendition.

The Conversation on Art, Identity, and Representation

Some critics view the casting and styling as provocative identity politics in action, aimed at shaking expectations rather than honoring tradition. Meanwhile, others see it as a necessary expansion of who gets to inhabit a powerful projection on stage. This production tapped into those cultural fault lines, sparking passionate responses from both sides.

The conversation has triggered theatrical critique and pushed into debates over gender, race, and what roles artists should be able to claim. In this case, Cynthia Erivo’s dual stance as a Black, queer woman added layers of complexity to the reaction. Whether viewed as courageous theatrical innovation or inappropriate reimagining, the production assuredly became one of the most talked-about artistic events of the year.

Disclaimer: This article was created with AI assistance and edited by a human for accuracy and clarity.

Read More: Photos Of Celebrities’ Extreme Weight Loss at Oscars is Stoking Concern